Why we have been discouraged from bedsharing? A look at the last 250 years

If we zoom right out and look at human history as a whole, separate sleep for babies is incredibly new. For most of our time on this planet, babies slept next to their mothers. On shared mats. In family beds. In single-room homes. Across cultures and continents, night-time closeness was not a parenting trend or a debated choice. It was simply how humans lived. Anthropologists consistently describe mother and infant proximity at night as the biological norm for our species.

 

So how did we move from that being ordinary and expected to strong messaging telling parents not to share a bed?
The answer is not one dramatic study or one moment in time. It is a slow shift shaped by culture, economics, religion, medicine and the changing structure of family life.

 

Industrialisation

Around 250 years ago, industrialisation began to reshape daily rhythms. Before factories and clock-based work, families often worked from home or nearby. Sleep was more flexible. Babies fed through the night without anyone worrying about a 6am alarm. Night waking was inconvenient, of course, but it was not colliding with a rigid industrial schedule.

As factory work expanded, punctuality and productivity became central to survival. Adults were expected to function on consolidated blocks of sleep in order to work long, structured days. Gradually, sleep became something ordered and private rather than communal and responsive. At the same time, housing began to change. As homes grew larger, separate bedrooms became possible. Nurseries became aspirational. The family bed, once practical and unremarkable, started to look old-fashioned.

Babies had not changed. Society had.

Religion

Religion and morality also played a role, particularly in Victorian Britain and parts of Europe. Independence, modesty and self-control were highly valued traits. Children were expected to grow into autonomy early. Sleeping alone became quietly associated with discipline and character. Sharing sleep was sometimes framed as indulgent or overly attached, rather than responsive.

Alongside this came new understandings of hygiene. As germ theory developed in the nineteenth century, separation within the home was sometimes equated with cleanliness and modernity. Distance meant safety. Order meant progress. Close physical contact, especially during sleep, no longer automatically felt like the healthiest option in a society newly aware of disease transmission.

None of this was necessarily driven by infant development research. It reflected the dominant be

 

liefs of the time.

SIDs

The twentieth century brought another powerful influence: fear. Sudden Infant Death Syndrome became a major public health concern. Researchers worked urgently to identify risk factors. In some studies, bedsharing appeared alongside increased risk, particularly in situations involving smoking, alcohol, unsafe sleep surfaces, soft bedding or prematurity.

Public health campaigns needed clarity. They needed simple messages that could reach millions of exhausted parents quickly. The clearest guidance was that babies should sleep in their own cot, on their own surface. Over time, that guidance became culturally embedded. In many Western countries, separate sleep came to symbolise safety and responsibility. Parents who chose differently often felt they had to justify themselves.

Yet the research picture has always been more nuanced than the headlines suggested. Risk is not evenly distributed. Context matters enormously. Sofa-sharing, smoking, substance use and unsafe bedding significantly increase danger. Planned bedsharing in safer circumstances is a very different situation. It is possible to hold both truths at once: unsafe environments increase risk, and human infants are biologically wired for proximity.

Work place pressures

Workforce participation added another layer. As more mothers entered paid employment outside the home, night-time rhythms had to align with early mornings and structured days. Western culture increasingly prizes uninterrupted adult sleep and early independence. Both are closely linked to economic productivity. A baby who sleeps alone and sleeps through the night fits neatly into that framework.

But biologically, babies still wake. They still feed frequently. They still seek closeness. Research suggests that proximity can support regulation of breathing, temperature and arousal. Bedsharing is strongly associated with longer and more frequent breastfeeding, partly because night feeds are more accessible. Parents sleeping close often rouse more easily and respond more quickly. Many families describe feeling calmer and more connected. Some breastfeeding mothers report that planned bedsharing allows them more overall rest compared to repeatedly getting up and down through the night.

 

Secure attachment

That does not mean bedsharing is the only path to secure attachment or healthy development. Many babies sleep separately and thrive beautifully. Secure relationships are built through consistent, responsive care over time, not through a single sleep arrangement.

When we look back at why bedsharing was discouraged, we do not find one defined point in time. We find industrialisation and changing work patterns. We find evolving housing design. We find religious and moral ideals. We find hygiene movements. We find simplified public health messaging during a time of understandable fear. We find a cultural emphasis on independence and productivity. Beliefs about infant sleep have always been shaped by the society around them.

Today, the conversation feels more layered. Public health guidance rightly focuses on reducing risk. Researchers acknowledge both biology and cultural diversity. Increasingly, the emphasis is on informed decision-making rather than blanket judgement, and parents are trying to do what they have always done. Navigating the advice and guidance and being responsive to their baby or children’s needs, trying to keep their babies safe, loved and nurtured. Also trying to get through the sleepless nights in a way that works for their family.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

14 + eighteen =